[ { "claim_id": "claim-001", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "partially supported", "plain_language_claim": "Descriptive male majority in CBI known related offenders", "technical_claim": "CBI public aggregate tables show Boulder known related offenders average about three quarters male for 2016-2025 in prior report outputs.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "No further evidence needed for this limited aggregate description; denominators remain police-reported CBI records only.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-002", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "unresolved because required data are unavailable", "plain_language_claim": "Differential police treatment", "technical_claim": "Public aggregate tables do not contain comparable pre-decision facts or no-arrest denominator.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Incident-level CAD/RMS, narratives, evidence metadata, probable-cause coding, agency/policy versions.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-003", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "unresolved because required data are unavailable", "plain_language_claim": "False-positive criminalization", "technical_claim": "No independent legal-sufficiency review sample yet.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Blinded record sample and legal-panel ratings.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-004", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "unresolved because required data are unavailable", "plain_language_claim": "False-negative underenforcement", "technical_claim": "No no-arrest/civil classified narrative sample yet.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "CAD/RMS no-arrest events and legal-panel ratings.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-005", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "unresolved because required data are unavailable", "plain_language_claim": "Downstream disparity", "technical_claim": "DA technical notes identify dashboard limitations; public docket sample is not sufficient.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "DA Action extract and Judicial Branch count-level compiled data.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-006", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "partially supported", "plain_language_claim": "Recent verified favorable outcomes for Boulder-nexus male accused parties exist", "technical_claim": "Cronin preliminary-hearing dismissal/settlement and Higdon reversal/remand are verified from public primary documents; Pollack had dropped charges but failed civil claims.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Exhaustive case discovery and denominator records to estimate rate/trend.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-007", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "not supported", "plain_language_claim": "Recent Boulder cases prove knowing false private allegations against men", "technical_claim": "Current seed proof matrix contains no Tier 1-2 false-report or private-allegation falsity finding.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Final false-reporting finding, admission, conviction, or equivalent merits finding tied to the allegation.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-008", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "contradicted by the primary record", "plain_language_claim": "Cronin settlement proves adjudicated damages or admitted liability", "technical_claim": "Council packet/proposed agreement shows $1 million settlement and compromise of disputed issues; no liability admission or damages verdict located.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Judgment/verdict or agreement term admitting liability/damages.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-009", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "not supported", "plain_language_claim": "Higdon reversal proves factual innocence or false accusation", "technical_claim": "Court of Appeals reversed/remanded for due-process/plain-error issue involving post-Miranda silence; no factual-innocence or false-report finding.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Later dismissal/exoneration, insufficiency ruling, or false-report finding if any.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-010", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "contradicted by the primary record", "plain_language_claim": "Pollack supports unjust prosecution trend", "technical_claim": "District court granted summary judgment to officer; probable cause remained even excluding disputed interview.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "None for current civil claim; appellate document still to preserve.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-011", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "not supported", "plain_language_claim": "46-case audit establishes male-specific false-accusation or overenforcement trend", "technical_claim": "Audit verifies case-management failures and time-barred DV cases, but public aggregate record lacks party sex/gender and favorable-outcome coding.", "stage": "cross-stage or source-specific", "estimand": "not a final confirmatory estimand unless stated", "unit_of_analysis": "claim", "eligible_population": "varies by claim", "conditioning_set": "", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder County agencies where applicable", "period_start": "", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "source-recorded where available; no name inference", "estimate_type": "qualitative status", "estimate": "", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "", "n_events": "", "denominator": "", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "", "covariate_set_id": "", "within_incident_design": "not available in public release", "robustness_summary": "pending restricted/case-level data", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "source_manifest_public.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "Deidentified case-level crosswalk with party sex/gender, allegation type, arrest/referral/filing/finality, and complaints/settlements.", "public_language_allowed": true }, { "claim_id": "claim-public-001", "hypothesis_id": "", "claim_status": "supported_as_public_descriptive_context", "plain_language_claim": "Boulder Police public domestic-labeled calls had higher arrest-coded disposition rates than public civil-labeled calls in 2023 through partial 2026.", "technical_claim": "Domestic-labeled calls had arrest-coded dispositions of 12.30% to 13.41%; civil-labeled calls had 0.28% to 1.30%. These are public call-disposition labels, not verified arrests or sex-disparity estimates.", "stage": "public call disposition", "estimand": "P(arrest-coded disposition | public call candidate family)", "unit_of_analysis": "public CAD call row", "eligible_population": "Boulder PD public calls matching screen terms", "conditioning_set": "none; descriptive", "agency_or_agencies": "Boulder Police Department", "period_start": "2023-01-01", "period_end": "2026-06-24", "comparison_groups": "domestic_label vs civil_label and other candidate labels", "recorded_sex_or_gender_definition": "not available in public call layer", "estimate_type": "percentage range by year", "estimate": "12.30-13.41", "ci_low": "", "ci_high": "", "confidence_level": "", "p_value": "", "q_value": "", "n_observations": "45361", "n_events": "", "denominator": "public screened Boulder PD call rows", "absolute_affected_count": "", "main_model_id": "descriptive-public-call-screen", "covariate_set_id": "none", "within_incident_design": "false", "robustness_summary": "public label screen only", "specifications_supporting": "", "specifications_total": "", "proof_tier": "", "source_ids": "boulder_pd_public_call_arrest_disposition_rates.csv", "analysis_commit": "", "data_snapshot_hash": "ba96daf88005c3a8c0223ae3597f2289b6c6e699bdad62f090cd175eb9b2f1e2", "preregistration_hash": "", "codebook_version": "public export 2026-06-24", "last_verified": "2026-06-24", "limitations": "No party sex/gender, relationship, narrative, probable-cause, referral, filing, or court-outcome fields.", "public_language_allowed": true } ]