Incivility on popular politics and news subreddits: An analysis of in-groups, community guidelines and relationships with social media engagement [Accepted October 27, 2025]
Publication: Social Science Computer Review, 2025
Abstract
Political and news subreddits are individualistic as it pertains to the incivility we might expect them to exhibit; some have clear in-group members , and all have varying degrees of content moderation policies. We sample submissions (n = 127,870) and comments (n = 2,576,049) from 20 of the most popular news and politics subreddits from June 4th, 2021, to June 4th, 2022. All subreddits appear to be mostly civil, with incivility most commonly occurring in comments. When incivility occurs, it tends to take on less-severe forms including insults, profanity, and general toxicity. Subreddits with with clear political in-groups did exhibit more insults, toxicity, profanity, and identity- based attacks. The more complex a subreddit’s moderation policies, the less incivility was observed. Finally, uncivil submissions do result in a mild increase in engagement, but given the overall low prevalence of incivility observed, it appears not to be integral to a subreddit’s overall engagement.
Keywords
incivility; Reddit; content moderation; community guidelines; in-groups 1.
How to Cite
Vargo, C. J. , & Hopp, T. (in press). Incivility on popular politics and news subreddits: An analysis of in-groups, community guidelines and relationships with social media engagement [Accepted October 27, 2025]. Social Science Computer Review.
Version and Rights
This is the author preprint.